Edition #038

|

17 Nov 2026

An academic with two affiliations

Imagine an academic employed full-time by University A who also holds an adjunct professorship at University B. As part of the adjunct appointment, they supervise doctoral students, mentor academic staff and advise on research activities.

However, carrying out these responsibilities requires access to research resources. The academic may need Scopus or Web of Science to identify relevant publications, examine citation patterns, assess journal quality, advise doctoral students on their literature reviews and download articles.

University B does not provide access to these databases, but University A does. The academic therefore logs in using their University A credentials and carries out the work for University B.

At first glance, there may not seem to be anything particularly unusual about this arrangement. The academic has legitimate access to the databases, is undertaking academic work and is helping another university. Surely, this is what academic collaboration is about?

But I think the situation deserves closer examination, especially when we consider the responsibilities of the university making the adjunct appointment.

Why do universities appoint adjunct academics?

Universities appoint adjunct academics for many reasons. Some appointments recognise an individual’s academic achievements or professional standing, while others are intended to establish relationships that benefit teaching, research and institutional development.

The responsibilities can differ considerably. Some adjunct appointments are largely honorary, with few expectations. Others involve substantial commitments, including doctoral supervision, teaching, mentoring, collaborative research and advice on institutional research strategy.

The financial arrangements can also vary. Some adjuncts undertake their responsibilities without payment, while others receive honoraria, consultancy fees or payments for specific activities. These distinctions matter when considering what an adjunct should reasonably be expected to contribute.

When a university appoints an adjunct professor, it is generally seeking access to that person’s expertise, experience, knowledge and professional networks. These are qualities the individual has developed throughout their career and can bring to different institutions.

However, does the appointment also bring access to the research infrastructure provided by the academic’s primary employer?

Expertise and infrastructure are different things

An academic’s expertise is portable. Their knowledge, experience and professional judgement do not disappear when they leave one university or collaborate with colleagues elsewhere.

However, many of the resources that academics use are not owned by them. They are provided by their institutions, often through expensive licensing agreements.

Scopus and Web of Science are obvious examples, but the issue extends further. Journal subscriptions, specialist software, research datasets, computing infrastructure and other resources may all be provided under institutional agreements.

When University A pays for access to these resources, it does so to support its own academic community and activities. It does not follow that an employee can use those resources to provide those services for another institution.

Consider an academic collaborating with a colleague at another university to produce a research paper. They use Scopus to identify relevant literature, assess previous research and develop their own contribution. This is a normal part of academic collaboration and, subject to the relevant licence, would generally be straightforward to justify.

Now consider the same academic being asked by University B to assess its research performance. They use University A’s Scopus subscription to carry out a bibliometric analysis and produce a report specifically for University B.

The activities may use similar research skills and information, but they are being undertaken for different purposes. In the second example, University B is receiving an institutional service that relies on resources provided by University A.

I think this distinction is central to the discussion.

What do the licensing agreements say?

An important consideration is that having legitimate access to a database does not necessarily mean that every use of that database is permitted.

Elsevier’s Scopus terms and conditions, updated in September 2026, permit authorised users to undertake scholarly or academic research. They also allow certain insights derived from Scopus to be used internally and externally, subject to restrictions on distributing the underlying content.

However, the terms also restrict commercial use, redistribution and other activities. There are specific provisions governing independent contractors and the purposes for which they may use the subscription.

The position with Web of Science is also worth examining.

A publicly available Clarivate licensing agreement covering 2023–2025 contains provisions restricting the use of licensed products or content to provide services outside the subscribing organisation.

Individual institutional agreements may differ, and I would not suggest that every activity undertaken for another university is automatically prohibited. The precise contractual arrangements and the nature of the activity are important.

However, the general principle is worth recognising. An academic may be an authorised user of Scopus or Web of Science while still facing restrictions on using that access to undertake roles for another organisation.

University library policies may impose additional requirements. Consequently, an academic cannot necessarily assume that a valid username and password provide permission to use a resource for any academic purpose.

Is there an ethical issue?

I believe there is, although the answer depends on the circumstances.

Academic research depends on collaboration, and universities should encourage their staff to work with colleagues at other institutions. Sharing knowledge, exchanging ideas and jointly undertaking research are fundamental parts of academic life.

I would be reluctant to argue that an academic using their primary university’s research resources to support a collaborative paper is necessarily doing anything wrong, provided that the use complies with the relevant agreements.

However, the position becomes more complicated when an academic undertakes formal responsibilities for another university.

Consider an adjunct professor supervising a doctoral student at University B. The supervisor may need access to Scopus or Web of Science to advise the student on the literature, identify suitable journals, examine developments in the research area or even download articles.

If University B does not provide that access, the supervisor might use the resources available through University A. They may not consider that there is a potential problem but, in my mind, there is.

A similar situation might arise when an adjunct mentors academic staff at University B. The mentoring could involve identifying publication opportunities, examining citation performance or evaluating research outputs. Again, these activities may rely on resources that University B has not provided. Again, I feel that this is problematic,

The ethical concerns become more substantial if the adjunct is undertaking a formal consultancy assignment or preparing a research performance report for University B using databases paid for by University A.

In such circumstances, the university receiving the benefit may not be contributing towards the cost of the resources used to deliver it.

Of course, an academic may believe they are simply using the tools available to them to undertake academic work. There may be no intention to misuse resources or disregard contractual restrictions.

But good intentions do not necessarily make an activity permissible. Equally, something might be contractually permitted while still raising questions about fairness and institutional responsibility. Given this, I think we need to shift our attention from the individual academic to the university making the appointment.

Are universities providing the resources needed?

For me, this is the central issue.

We could debate whether an academic should use their existing Scopus or Web of Science access when working as an adjunct. However, that risks overlooking the responsibilities of the institution expecting the work to be undertaken.

If University B appoints someone to supervise doctoral students, it has a responsibility to ensure that those students receive appropriate supervision and research support. Similarly, if it appoints an adjunct to mentor academic staff or advise on research strategy, it should consider what resources are needed to fulfil those responsibilities.

I am not suggesting that every adjunct should automatically receive unrestricted access to every database, software package or research facility. Some appointments involve relatively limited activities, while others require substantial institutional support.

The resources provided should reflect the agreed responsibilities.

However, I do question whether it is reasonable for a university to expect an adjunct to carry out formal duties while assuming that the necessary research infrastructure will be available through another institution.

There is also a practical consideration that could have serious implications, particularly for doctoral supervision.

An adjunct might initially be employed by another university and have access to extensive research resources. However, what happens if they retire, move to another university, move to a role outside of academia or lose access to their primary institution’s subscriptions?

The adjunct may still have the same responsibilities towards University B but no longer have access to the resources they previously relied upon.

Doctoral supervision can continue for several years. It seems unreasonable for a student’s access to appropriate supervisory support to depend on whether their supervisor happens to retain access to research resources through another affiliation.

The university awarding the degree remains responsible for the quality of the supervision it provides, regardless of its employment arrangements of individual supervisors.

This is why I believe universities should be more explicit about the resources associated with adjunct appointments.

Are universities creating hidden dependencies?

There is a wider governance issue here.

Universities frequently highlight their networks of adjunct, honorary and visiting professors. These appointments can be valuable, particularly when they bring specialist expertise into the institution, establish research collaborations and strengthen relationships with the wider academic community.

However, there is a difference between having access to academic expertise and having the institutional capacity to support the activities that expertise enables.

A university might have an impressive network of adjunct professors who contribute to doctoral supervision, staff development and research activities. But if those academics rely heavily on facilities provided by their primary employers, the university may be more dependent on external infrastructure than it realises.

I am not suggesting that this is necessarily deliberate. Universities may simply have developed arrangements over many years without fully considering the licensing and resource implications.

Nor am I suggesting that every adjunct appointment creates such a dependency. In many cases, the necessary infrastructure may already be available, or the responsibilities may not require additional resources.

Nevertheless, university leaders should understand what is required to deliver the academic activities for which their institutions are responsible. This is particularly relevant when universities use their networks of adjunct academics to demonstrate research capability or postgraduate supervisory capacity.

The number of academics associated with an institution is one measure of its academic resources. Whether those academics have the support needed to undertake their responsibilities is another.

What should universities do differently?

I do not believe the answer is to discourage adjunct appointments or make academic collaboration unnecessarily difficult. Both can contribute significantly to the quality of teaching, research and institutional development.

Instead, I would encourage universities to give greater consideration to the relationship between adjunct responsibilities and institutional support.

When making an appointment, the university should establish what the adjunct is expected to do and what resources are required. If the responsibilities include doctoral supervision, mentoring or research assessment, access to relevant databases and other research facilities may need to be addressed explicitly.

This does not necessarily mean purchasing every available subscription. There may be legitimate alternatives, including providing appropriate institutional access, securing permission for specific activities or adjusting the nature of the work to reflect the available resources.

Equally, universities providing database subscriptions should make their policies clear about how those resources may be used by academics who hold appointments elsewhere. It should not be left entirely to individual academics to interpret complex licensing agreements and decide whether their activities are permissible.

A relatively straightforward discussion between the adjunct, the appointing university and the relevant library services could avoid considerable uncertainty.

What exactly is a university appointing?

I began with an academic who holds appointments at two universities and uses the research resources of one to undertake responsibilities at the other.

I suspect that similar situations arise in many institutions, although I have not seen evidence of how widespread the practice is.

There are legitimate reasons why academics might use resources available through one affiliation while collaborating with another institution. Equally, there are circumstances in which providing a service to another university using those resources may be contractually restricted or ethically questionable.

I would not want to discourage collaboration or suggest that academics should avoid making their expertise available to other institutions. Quite the opposite. Adjunct appointments can bring considerable benefits to universities, their staff and their students.

However, universities should recognise that an academic’s expertise and the infrastructure supporting their work are not necessarily the same thing. If an institution appoints someone to undertake particular responsibilities, it should consider whether it is providing the resources needed to fulfil them, rather than assuming those resources will come from elsewhere.

When a university appoints an adjunct professor, is it appointing their expertise, or is it also expecting access to another university’s research resources?

I would be particularly interested in hearing the experiences of adjunct academics, university leaders and librarians. Do universities generally provide the resources needed for adjuncts to undertake their responsibilities, or is it commonly assumed that they will bring those resources with them?


I publish two free newsletters each week

Governance & Research in HE
A weekly brief for higher education leaders and researchers examining governance, leadership and research in practice.
https://buff.ly/GhsZqVl

Publishing with Integrity
Examining scholarly publishing through an ethical lens, challenging assumptions and supporting academic career development.
https://buff.ly/WiG1yFb

If you subscribe, you will be alerted whenever I publish a new edition.


About the author

Professor Graham Kendall has held senior leadership positions in higher education, including Vice-Chancellor, Provost/CEO, Deputy Vice-Chancellor, Pro-Vice-Chancellor and Vice-Provost roles. He is an Emeritus Professor at the University of Nottingham and has published more than 300 peer-reviewed papers.

His interests include university leadership and governance, research strategy, artificial intelligence and research integrity.

Originally published on LinkedIn

This edition was first published as part of my LinkedIn newsletter. If you use LinkedIn, I recommend reading it there, where you can also join the discussion. This version is provided particularly for readers who do not have a LinkedIn account.

Would you like to know when the next edition is published?

Receive an email whenever I publish a new edition of my newsletter.