The invitation and the qualification
I receive publishing invitations offering fee waivers, but some still require a payment of a DOI fee. In the invitations I am referring to, the amount of the DOI charge is not stated.
One email I received said “Submissions received on or before the August 20th, 2026 will be provided with complete fee waiver (DOI charges are applicable).”
The email continued “Send us your manuscript as an attachment to this email.”
If I submitted a paper based on this, I would do so, unaware of how much the DOI charges were going to be.
It was only because I enquired, that I found out that this fee was 300 USD. The email I received said “We can confirm that the DOI and associated publication processing charge is 300 USD.” Just to note that the DOI fee now includes an ‘associated publication processing charge’, which was not mentioned before.
If you want to see this post, you can see it on LinkedIn and X.
So, the publication charge may have been waived, but if I had accepted the invitation I would still be sent a bill, importantly, of an unknown amount.
There is nothing inherently contradictory about waiving one charge while retaining another. A publisher might offer a partial waiver, subsidise particular services or remove its article processing charge (APC) while requiring payment for something else. The question is whether the invitation makes the financial commitment clear, which was not the case in the example given above.
If an author’s first impression is that publication will be free, it is important that the publisher explains that it will still cost several hundred dollars. That explanation should be part of the offer itself, rather than something the author has to discover.
What does a DOI fee cover?
A digital object identifier, or DOI, provides a persistent identifier (often referred to as a perma-link) for an article. It helps readers and systems locate the work even when its web address changes, assuming that the associated record is maintained.
Crossref’s published registration fee for a current journal article in 2026 is USD 1 per record. Publishers may also pay annual membership fees and incur costs for preparing metadata, operating systems and employing staff, while some obtain these services through intermediaries that charge their own fees. The USD 1 registration price does not represent the publisher’s complete cost, but that still leaves a reasonable question when an author is asked to pay USD 300 for a DOI. What, precisely, does the charge cover?
If the payment includes production, administration, metadata preparation and other publishing services, the publisher should explain that. They should also explain what the usual APC covers and there should be clear separation so that a DOI fee is not just replacing the APC. Describing a broader publishing charge simply as a DOI fee could leave authors with the impression that the amount is an unavoidable payment to an external organisation.
A waiver of what?
The word “waiver” tells us that something has been removed, but it does not necessarily tell us what remains. A full waiver of an article processing charge may still be a partial waiver of the total cost of publication.
That distinction matters to an author deciding whether to submit. An invitation announcing a waived publication fee, followed by a less prominent compulsory processing charge, may be technically accurate while still creating a misleading overall impression.
Consider a hypothetical invitation offering a waiver of a USD 1,000 article processing charge while retaining a mandatory USD 350 payment. The information most useful to the author is that publication will cost USD 350. The amount of the advertised saving does not answer whether the author can afford to proceed.
Publishers should make the final payable amount crystal clear rather than promoting the waiver without clearly stating the remaining charge of several hundred dollars. Authors should not need to understand how a publisher divides its charges before they can establish what they will have to pay.
Disclosure has to arrive in time
A compulsory charge explained clearly before submission allows an author to make an informed decision and, perhaps, importantly, ask for that amount of supporting funds from their university. A charge revealed after review or acceptance arrives when the author has already invested time and may be reluctant to start again elsewhere. It may also cause issues, as they now need to go and ask for those funds, rather than it being approved already.
Moreover, the author might face a graduation deadline, a funding requirement or an approaching performance review. Those circumstances can make an unexpected payment difficult to refuse, even when it would have changed the original decision to submit.
We should distinguish between a charge disclosed in the initial invitation and one introduced later. Both deserve clear explanations, but a late disclosure creates an additional problem because the author’s practical options may have narrowed.
The joint transparency principles developed by COPE, DOAJ, OASPA and WAME already say that author fees should be clearly stated, easy to find and presented as early in the submission process as possible. They also require clarity about waiver arrangements.
That provides a foundation, but we could make the expectation more concrete. An author should be able to establish the full compulsory cost before submitting a manuscript.
A quotation the publisher will honour
I would like publishers to provide a written quotation identifying the manuscript, the applicable charges, the agreed waiver and the final amount payable. The quotation should also state the currency, when payment becomes due and any conditions that could change the total.
Where charges depend on article length or another variable, the calculation should be clear, ideally with a maximum amount. Optional services should be identified separately and require the author’s agreement.
The publisher would commit to honouring that quotation if the manuscript is accepted under the stated conditions. This would be a commitment about price, while the editorial decision would remain subject to the journal’s review process.
A waiver could be confirmed in equally straightforward language: the article processing charge has been waived, a specified compulsory charge remains, and the total payable is a stated amount. That would give the author a usable answer rather than a collection of fee categories.
The detailed quotation should be provided and agreed by the corresponding author before submission is completed.
Integrity includes the publishing offer
A separate DOI charge does not, by itself, establish that a journal is predatory. Nor does a high price alone tell us whether the publisher provides a worthwhile service.
However, the way a publisher presents its prices is relevant to its integrity. Authors should be able to trust the financial information in a publishing invitation, just as publishers expect authors to provide accurate information about themselves and their research.
A partial waiver can be valuable, provided it is presented clearly. The difficulty arises when the language of generosity receives more attention than the payment the author must still make.
Before accepting a waiver, I would ask the publisher to confirm the total compulsory amount in writing. More fundamentally, I would ask why that information was not already prominent in the offer.
Do you have any thoughts about the issues discussed in the edition?
I publish two free newsletters each week
Governance & Research in HE
A weekly brief for higher education leaders and researchers examining governance, leadership and research in practice.
https://buff.ly/GhsZqVl
Publishing with Integrity
Examining scholarly publishing through an ethical lens, challenging assumptions and supporting academic career development.
https://buff.ly/WiG1yFb
If you subscribe, you will be alerted whenever I publish a new edition.
About the author
Professor Graham Kendall has held senior leadership positions in higher education, including Vice-Chancellor, Provost/CEO, Deputy Vice-Chancellor, Pro-Vice-Chancellor and Vice-Provost roles. He is an Emeritus Professor at the University of Nottingham and has published more than 300 peer-reviewed papers. His interests include university leadership and governance, research strategy, artificial intelligence and research integrity.